Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference? Topic is solved
- Gregski
- Posts: 2546
- Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2021 10:28 am
- Location: Sacramento, California
- Has thanked: 449 times
- Been thanked: 788 times
- Contact:
Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
please forgive me for a non EV related inquiry, but I know smarts lives here so I'm sure you can explain it to me
not sure if you heard of these solar panel grid tie inverters but they are very simple to install, you just connect some solar panels to this box and then plug the box into the wall outlet, and no batteries needed
my question is, what's the difference between the one that is 12 volts vs the one that is 24 volts, I mean if I was to tear them open what electronic component would be different
please talk to me like I'm 8 years old (I mean it)
Y&H 1000W Grid Tie Inverter Stackable MPPT Pure Sine Wave DC15-28V Solar Input AC90-140V Output for 12V Solar Panel
Y&H 1000W Grid Tie Inverter Stackable MPPT Pure Sine Wave DC30-45V Solar Input AC90-140V Output for 24V 30V 36V PV Panel
not sure if you heard of these solar panel grid tie inverters but they are very simple to install, you just connect some solar panels to this box and then plug the box into the wall outlet, and no batteries needed
my question is, what's the difference between the one that is 12 volts vs the one that is 24 volts, I mean if I was to tear them open what electronic component would be different
please talk to me like I'm 8 years old (I mean it)
Y&H 1000W Grid Tie Inverter Stackable MPPT Pure Sine Wave DC15-28V Solar Input AC90-140V Output for 12V Solar Panel
Y&H 1000W Grid Tie Inverter Stackable MPPT Pure Sine Wave DC30-45V Solar Input AC90-140V Output for 24V 30V 36V PV Panel
"I don't need to understand how it works, I just need to understand how to make it work!" ~ EV Greg
- johu
- Site Admin
- Posts: 6323
- Joined: Thu Nov 08, 2018 10:52 pm
- Location: Kassel/Germany
- Has thanked: 250 times
- Been thanked: 1316 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
Inside it you will find an isolated DC-DC converter and the actual sine wave inverter. DC-DC converter works much like your laptop power supply only that it turns 12V into 250V or thereabouts. It has input capacitors which might be rated different (more capacity, less voltage for the 12V model), transistors may even be the same but they do need to switch twice the current at 12V, so may be stronger or more. And finally the transformer winding ratio will be like 1:20 for the 12V model and 1:10 for the 30V model.
Support R/D and forum on Patreon: https://patreon.com/openinverter - Subscribe on odysee: https://odysee.com/@openinverter:9
- Gregski
- Posts: 2546
- Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2021 10:28 am
- Location: Sacramento, California
- Has thanked: 449 times
- Been thanked: 788 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
wow you sure seem to know a lot about Inverters, ever thought about applying all you know to EVing?johu wrote: ↑Fri Jul 22, 2022 3:30 pmInside it you will find an isolated DC-DC converter and the actual sine wave inverter. DC-DC converter works much like your laptop power supply only that it turns 12V into 250V or thereabouts. It has input capacitors which might be rated different (more capacity, less voltage for the 12V model), transistors may even be the same but they do need to switch twice the current at 12V, so may be stronger or more. And finally the transformer winding ratio will be like 1:20 for the 12V model and 1:10 for the 30V model.
"I don't need to understand how it works, I just need to understand how to make it work!" ~ EV Greg
-
- Posts: 3438
- Joined: Mon Dec 24, 2018 1:37 pm
- Location: Slovenia
- Has thanked: 101 times
- Been thanked: 305 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
Well i can just comment that i dont know where would openinverter be without him .Gregski wrote: ↑Fri Jul 22, 2022 3:52 pmwow you sure seem to know a lot about Inverters, ever thought about applying all you know to EVing?johu wrote: ↑Fri Jul 22, 2022 3:30 pmInside it you will find an isolated DC-DC converter and the actual sine wave inverter. DC-DC converter works much like your laptop power supply only that it turns 12V into 250V or thereabouts. It has input capacitors which might be rated different (more capacity, less voltage for the 12V model), transistors may even be the same but they do need to switch twice the current at 12V, so may be stronger or more. And finally the transformer winding ratio will be like 1:20 for the 12V model and 1:10 for the 30V model.
- johu
- Site Admin
- Posts: 6323
- Joined: Thu Nov 08, 2018 10:52 pm
- Location: Kassel/Germany
- Has thanked: 250 times
- Been thanked: 1316 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
EVs will never catch on, I heard
And what would the world be without openinverter? A safer place, some say
Support R/D and forum on Patreon: https://patreon.com/openinverter - Subscribe on odysee: https://odysee.com/@openinverter:9
- Gregski
- Posts: 2546
- Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2021 10:28 am
- Location: Sacramento, California
- Has thanked: 449 times
- Been thanked: 788 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
just came across this video of a 1000 watt comparison to a 1300 watt inverter of the same brand, not exactly what I was trying to compare 12 volt vs 24 volt but the findings were surprising none the less
"I don't need to understand how it works, I just need to understand how to make it work!" ~ EV Greg
-
- Posts: 154
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2021 5:44 pm
- Location: Finland
- Has thanked: 39 times
- Been thanked: 7 times
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
Are these Chinese "grid tied" solar inverters legal anywhere?
In Finland grid tie inverter requires VDE-AR-N-4105:2018, which is newest standard. Older VDE-AR-N-4105 2011-08 inverters are not allowed anymore for new installations. And VDE0126-1-1 has never been legal.
I would not install grid tied inverter without proofed islanding protection. Which means in case of grid fails or power cut on service etc, inverter needs to stop supplying the grid. Fail to do so might even kill electrician.
If someone knows if there is external certified islanding protection modules, I would be happy to hear!
In Finland grid tie inverter requires VDE-AR-N-4105:2018, which is newest standard. Older VDE-AR-N-4105 2011-08 inverters are not allowed anymore for new installations. And VDE0126-1-1 has never been legal.
I would not install grid tied inverter without proofed islanding protection. Which means in case of grid fails or power cut on service etc, inverter needs to stop supplying the grid. Fail to do so might even kill electrician.
If someone knows if there is external certified islanding protection modules, I would be happy to hear!
-
- Posts: 3438
- Joined: Mon Dec 24, 2018 1:37 pm
- Location: Slovenia
- Has thanked: 101 times
- Been thanked: 305 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
This is the reason i am separating my 5kW battery solar inverter from grid tied system. Former is supplying the house after the junction with the latter.
It means i had to remodel house fuses to single phase with corresponding GFI. I only left 3phase loads such as heat pump and evse connected in the usual way.
That way if grid drops the ball battery inverter will supply the house still no danger to electicians working on the grid.
It means i had to remodel house fuses to single phase with corresponding GFI. I only left 3phase loads such as heat pump and evse connected in the usual way.
That way if grid drops the ball battery inverter will supply the house still no danger to electicians working on the grid.
- Peter
- Posts: 319
- Joined: Fri Dec 14, 2018 9:07 pm
- Location: North West Lancs, UK
- Been thanked: 9 times
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
Hi Guys. Have a read here...
https://www.solar-electric.com/learning ... r-outages/
https://www.solar-electric.com/learning ... r-outages/
- Gregski
- Posts: 2546
- Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2021 10:28 am
- Location: Sacramento, California
- Has thanked: 449 times
- Been thanked: 788 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
here we go again for [ahem] SCIENCE, The Greg went out and bought a cheap AMAZON 24 volt inverter so that he can have you guys hand hold him as he performs a stare-and-compare-ectomy of the two models
I love how you can look at one AMAZON cheap inverter description and see 3 different sets of completely different arbitrary specs
I love how you can look at one AMAZON cheap inverter description and see 3 different sets of completely different arbitrary specs
"I don't need to understand how it works, I just need to understand how to make it work!" ~ EV Greg
- Gregski
- Posts: 2546
- Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2021 10:28 am
- Location: Sacramento, California
- Has thanked: 449 times
- Been thanked: 788 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
I wanted to do this on my Hübner Junior Electronic Workbench in the privacy of my own home office, but the wife insisted I work on them on our formal dining table
"I don't need to understand how it works, I just need to understand how to make it work!" ~ EV Greg
- Gregski
- Posts: 2546
- Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2021 10:28 am
- Location: Sacramento, California
- Has thanked: 449 times
- Been thanked: 788 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
so let's start with the DC input side and them external (pronounced: "we did a crappy job of designing this thing and now you get to replace the fuses") fuses
both units appear to be equipped with three 30 amp fuses in parallel if I understand the DC wiring correctly on the DC input side
both units appear to be equipped with three 30 amp fuses in parallel if I understand the DC wiring correctly on the DC input side
12 volt model | 24/36 volt model |
---|---|
no pic cause it looked the same | |
no pic cause it looked the same |
"I don't need to understand how it works, I just need to understand how to make it work!" ~ EV Greg
- Gregski
- Posts: 2546
- Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2021 10:28 am
- Location: Sacramento, California
- Has thanked: 449 times
- Been thanked: 788 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
so in order to slide the steel or pot metal bottom cover off, I stripped I mean undid four screws on each end
I believe this is the AC output side, and I gotta tell you those three, red, white, and black wires are soooo skinny the pic doesn't do them injustice
input fan sucks the air in on the AC side
that's cute
I believe this is the AC output side, and I gotta tell you those three, red, white, and black wires are soooo skinny the pic doesn't do them injustice
input fan sucks the air in on the AC side
that's cute
"I don't need to understand how it works, I just need to understand how to make it work!" ~ EV Greg
- Gregski
- Posts: 2546
- Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2021 10:28 am
- Location: Sacramento, California
- Has thanked: 449 times
- Been thanked: 788 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
and here are the circus boards, they are the exact same MODEL: G1I-1400W number and even have the same INPUT: 11-55 VDC rating, just have a different born on date
12 volt model | 24/36 volt model |
---|---|
"I don't need to understand how it works, I just need to understand how to make it work!" ~ EV Greg
- Gregski
- Posts: 2546
- Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2021 10:28 am
- Location: Sacramento, California
- Has thanked: 449 times
- Been thanked: 788 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
here's the 24/36 volt model coming apart
"I don't need to understand how it works, I just need to understand how to make it work!" ~ EV Greg
- Gregski
- Posts: 2546
- Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2021 10:28 am
- Location: Sacramento, California
- Has thanked: 449 times
- Been thanked: 788 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
mandatory stare and compare
"I don't need to understand how it works, I just need to understand how to make it work!" ~ EV Greg
- Gregski
- Posts: 2546
- Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2021 10:28 am
- Location: Sacramento, California
- Has thanked: 449 times
- Been thanked: 788 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
the caps appear to be the same 50v 2200uF
12 volt model | 24/36 volt model |
---|---|
"I don't need to understand how it works, I just need to understand how to make it work!" ~ EV Greg
- Gregski
- Posts: 2546
- Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2021 10:28 am
- Location: Sacramento, California
- Has thanked: 449 times
- Been thanked: 788 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
these small and large transistors appear to be the same as well, hard to see the part numbers, here's what I think they are
Small Guys
CQ1408 U2080G - 20.0 Ampere Heatsink Common Cathode Ultra Fast Recovery Rectifiers
Bigger Ones
1XFH44N50P S11855
PolarTM HiperFETTM
Power MOSFET
Small Guys
CQ1408 U2080G - 20.0 Ampere Heatsink Common Cathode Ultra Fast Recovery Rectifiers
Bigger Ones
1XFH44N50P S11855
PolarTM HiperFETTM
Power MOSFET
"I don't need to understand how it works, I just need to understand how to make it work!" ~ EV Greg
- Gregski
- Posts: 2546
- Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2021 10:28 am
- Location: Sacramento, California
- Has thanked: 449 times
- Been thanked: 788 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
so this leads us to the yellow brick road(s) which have different part numbers it would be great if someone could explain what their roles are, I'm thinking filters of sorts?
12 volt model | 24/36 volt model |
---|---|
XJ1400W-PQ1028 | XJ1400W-PQ2250 |
"I don't need to understand how it works, I just need to understand how to make it work!" ~ EV Greg
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
Those are the high frequency transformers, most high frequency inverters like this work this way:
1. low voltage dc is pulsed into these transformers at very high frequency with a bunch of low-ish voltage MOSFETS. This allows a lot of power to be put through the transformers without requiring a huge iron core. For comparison imagine the size and weight of the transformer you'd need to push 1000w continuously. Probably the size of the entire inverter.
2. The output of the transformers is rectified, possibly by discrete diodes that look like MOSFETS, or in lower power applications could be normal diodes. The thing is at this point, the voltage is around ~170vdc (for 110v inverters) and around ~340vdc for 220v inverters. Note that the dc voltage is higher than the AC voltage because AC voltage is rms, which is a sort of average, but the peak voltage of the sine wave is the DC voltage you're seeing here.
Now the good thing about these high voltages is that to get the 1000w rating, at 120v its only 8-9a going through here, so not as beefy components required in the HV section.
3. In an off-grid inverter you'd have a large-ish capacitor bank to hold the HV and stabilize it, but in a grid tie inverter its not as neccessary because there's no surges and most noise will be supressed later in the circuit.
4. Once you have your HVDC, it goes into an H-bridge, which is always in sets of 4. This is a similar concept to reversing relays, basically they are used to switch the high voltage in a certain way that they can reverse it, so you can get AC from it. Those are the IXFH44N50P transistors you see. They are 500v rated.
5. An SPWM signal is fed into the transistors, to make the output as close to a sine wave as possible. Though it needs a lot of filtering to get rid of all the switching noise.
6. Output of the transistors goes into an LC filter, which is an inductor in series with the output, and a (low capacity) capacitor after the inductor to neutral. This turns the rather noisy sine wave into a basically perfect sine wave (depending on how good the filtering is). Then it just goes out into the utility, and of course there's a lot of microcontrollers in the way, making sure it isn't overheating, outputting when theres no grid, overpowered, or the grid voltage is too high. For example, if the grid voltage is 110v, the inverter will push power in, so it might go up to 110.1v or w/e. If your grid is too weak and your grid-tie inverter is too powerful, it may raise the voltage above acceptable range and a PROPER inverter would realize and either shut down or reduce output. Now with a 1000w inverter I doubt this scenario would happen, although its entirely doable.
But yeah most likely the only difference between the two is the windings of the LV-HV transformers, I'd assume that the higher voltage one has 2x the turns but with thinner wire on the primary side. Secondary is probably the same.
Thats basically the issue with inverters, there's no one-size-fits-all when it comes to voltage ranges. IMO, the higher the voltage the better, because there's less losses the higher you go. That's why you have these solar gridtie inverters that can do 70kw that are smaller lighter and cheaper than 12kw low voltage inverters. But of course thats a different topic b/c going off-grid with high voltage is rather complicated due to having so many batteries in series, and of course the entry cost because you need a large number of solar panels in series to even get started.
1. low voltage dc is pulsed into these transformers at very high frequency with a bunch of low-ish voltage MOSFETS. This allows a lot of power to be put through the transformers without requiring a huge iron core. For comparison imagine the size and weight of the transformer you'd need to push 1000w continuously. Probably the size of the entire inverter.
2. The output of the transformers is rectified, possibly by discrete diodes that look like MOSFETS, or in lower power applications could be normal diodes. The thing is at this point, the voltage is around ~170vdc (for 110v inverters) and around ~340vdc for 220v inverters. Note that the dc voltage is higher than the AC voltage because AC voltage is rms, which is a sort of average, but the peak voltage of the sine wave is the DC voltage you're seeing here.
Now the good thing about these high voltages is that to get the 1000w rating, at 120v its only 8-9a going through here, so not as beefy components required in the HV section.
3. In an off-grid inverter you'd have a large-ish capacitor bank to hold the HV and stabilize it, but in a grid tie inverter its not as neccessary because there's no surges and most noise will be supressed later in the circuit.
4. Once you have your HVDC, it goes into an H-bridge, which is always in sets of 4. This is a similar concept to reversing relays, basically they are used to switch the high voltage in a certain way that they can reverse it, so you can get AC from it. Those are the IXFH44N50P transistors you see. They are 500v rated.
5. An SPWM signal is fed into the transistors, to make the output as close to a sine wave as possible. Though it needs a lot of filtering to get rid of all the switching noise.
6. Output of the transistors goes into an LC filter, which is an inductor in series with the output, and a (low capacity) capacitor after the inductor to neutral. This turns the rather noisy sine wave into a basically perfect sine wave (depending on how good the filtering is). Then it just goes out into the utility, and of course there's a lot of microcontrollers in the way, making sure it isn't overheating, outputting when theres no grid, overpowered, or the grid voltage is too high. For example, if the grid voltage is 110v, the inverter will push power in, so it might go up to 110.1v or w/e. If your grid is too weak and your grid-tie inverter is too powerful, it may raise the voltage above acceptable range and a PROPER inverter would realize and either shut down or reduce output. Now with a 1000w inverter I doubt this scenario would happen, although its entirely doable.
But yeah most likely the only difference between the two is the windings of the LV-HV transformers, I'd assume that the higher voltage one has 2x the turns but with thinner wire on the primary side. Secondary is probably the same.
Thats basically the issue with inverters, there's no one-size-fits-all when it comes to voltage ranges. IMO, the higher the voltage the better, because there's less losses the higher you go. That's why you have these solar gridtie inverters that can do 70kw that are smaller lighter and cheaper than 12kw low voltage inverters. But of course thats a different topic b/c going off-grid with high voltage is rather complicated due to having so many batteries in series, and of course the entry cost because you need a large number of solar panels in series to even get started.
- Gregski
- Posts: 2546
- Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2021 10:28 am
- Location: Sacramento, California
- Has thanked: 449 times
- Been thanked: 788 times
- Contact:
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
Wow, thank you so much, very informative.lompilomp wrote: ↑Sat Aug 27, 2022 9:09 pm Those are the high frequency transformers, most high frequency inverters like this work this way:
1. low voltage dc is pulsed into these transformers at very high frequency with a bunch of low-ish voltage MOSFETS. This allows a lot of power to be put through the transformers without requiring a huge iron core. For comparison imagine the size and weight of the transformer you'd need to push 1000w continuously. Probably the size of the entire inverter.
2. The output of the transformers is rectified, possibly by discrete diodes that look like MOSFETS, or in lower power applications could be normal diodes. The thing is at this point, the voltage is around ~170vdc (for 110v inverters) and around ~340vdc for 220v inverters. Note that the dc voltage is higher than the AC voltage because AC voltage is rms, which is a sort of average, but the peak voltage of the sine wave is the DC voltage you're seeing here.
Now the good thing about these high voltages is that to get the 1000w rating, at 120v its only 8-9a going through here, so not as beefy components required in the HV section.
3. In an off-grid inverter you'd have a large-ish capacitor bank to hold the HV and stabilize it, but in a grid tie inverter its not as neccessary because there's no surges and most noise will be supressed later in the circuit.
4. Once you have your HVDC, it goes into an H-bridge, which is always in sets of 4. This is a similar concept to reversing relays, basically they are used to switch the high voltage in a certain way that they can reverse it, so you can get AC from it. Those are the IXFH44N50P transistors you see. They are 500v rated.
5. An SPWM signal is fed into the transistors, to make the output as close to a sine wave as possible. Though it needs a lot of filtering to get rid of all the switching noise.
6. Output of the transistors goes into an LC filter, which is an inductor in series with the output, and a (low capacity) capacitor after the inductor to neutral. This turns the rather noisy sine wave into a basically perfect sine wave (depending on how good the filtering is). Then it just goes out into the utility, and of course there's a lot of microcontrollers in the way, making sure it isn't overheating, outputting when theres no grid, overpowered, or the grid voltage is too high. For example, if the grid voltage is 110v, the inverter will push power in, so it might go up to 110.1v or w/e. If your grid is too weak and your grid-tie inverter is too powerful, it may raise the voltage above acceptable range and a PROPER inverter would realize and either shut down or reduce output. Now with a 1000w inverter I doubt this scenario would happen, although its entirely doable.
But yeah most likely the only difference between the two is the windings of the LV-HV transformers, I'd assume that the higher voltage one has 2x the turns but with thinner wire on the primary side. Secondary is probably the same.
Thats basically the issue with inverters, there's no one-size-fits-all when it comes to voltage ranges. IMO, the higher the voltage the better, because there's less losses the higher you go. That's why you have these solar gridtie inverters that can do 70kw that are smaller lighter and cheaper than 12kw low voltage inverters. But of course thats a different topic b/c going off-grid with high voltage is rather complicated due to having so many batteries in series, and of course the entry cost because you need a large number of solar panels in series to even get started.
"I don't need to understand how it works, I just need to understand how to make it work!" ~ EV Greg
Re: Grid Tie Inverters - What's the difference?
I have some of those bad boys connected to the output of my 5kVA 48v low frequency inverter. They feed the inverter AC Output and allow me to run bigger things like my 24kBTU A/C unit with my entire home.
Just changed the fans on them, the default one sucks.
Just changed the fans on them, the default one sucks.